HomeReal Estate & DevelopmentBidding war for South Orange apartment building yields $4.1M sale; $300K over...

Bidding war for South Orange apartment building yields $4.1M sale; $300K over asking price

21-unit structure adjacent to thriving downtown, Seton Hall University

A 21-unit apartment building in South Orange has been sold for $4.1 million in a deal brokered by Sheldon Gross Realty President Marcy Gross and Controller Theresa Davies, in conjunction with Berkadia Senior Director Nat Gambuzza and Director Tim Blashford.

The 9,600-square-foot, two-story structure is located at 123 Milligan Place, immediately adjacent to the community’s vibrant downtown.

“There’s currently a great deal of interest in acquiring apartment buildings as investment properties,” Gross said. “The trend certainly held in this case. The building was listed for $3.8 million, received multiple above-asking offers during the course of just one week, and ultimately sold for a bit more than $300,000 beyond than the listing price.”

Featuring a spacious, rear parking area, the apartment building is an easy walk to Seton Hall University and multiple local restaurants and cafes. In addition, it’s no more than a 10-minute drive from Interstate 78, the Garden State Parkway and South Mountain Reservation.

Related Articles

ICON Real Estate Advisors arranges $7.95M sale of East Orange multifamily property 

ICON Real Estate Advisors has arranged the $7.95 million sale of a 58-unit garden-style multifamily property at 223 Prospect St. in East Orange. ICON represented...

JLL leases over 10K square feet in deals at Bedminster shopping center

JLL said Wednesday that it has leased 10,620 square feet of retail space at The Hills Village Center, a 101,453-square-foot shopping center anchored by Kings Food Market in Bedminster.  JLL...

Marcus & Millichap report: Retail market tightens as vacancy hits historic low

Marcus & Millichap, a leading commercial real estate brokerage firm specializing in investment sales, financing, research and advisory services, has published its 2026 Northern...

Colliers brokers sale of vacant office building in Warren  

Colliers, a leading diversified professional services and investment management company, has arranged the sale of 45 Technology Drive, a 45,800-square-foot vacant office building in...

The Park in Berkeley Heights announces 6 new retailers

The Park, a 185-acre mixed-use campus in Berkeley Heights, announced that six new retailers will occupy The District at The Park in July 2026. The...

Vital Care, national infusion therapy provider, signs lease at Parsippany Commons

Larken Associates, a commercial and residential real estate firm, said Vital Care of Morristown, a franchise of Vital Care Infusion Services, signed a 3,151-square-foot...

Latest Articles

New Portal Bridge used ahead of schedule as delays impact NJ Transit riders

Train service between Newark and New York was limited Friday, with delays of up to an hour due to overhead wire issues at the...

What an ‘AI-proof’ job entails — and who’s at risk of losing out

The Bureau of Labor Statistics’ February jobs report revealed 92,000 losses in nonfarm sectors. For job seekers, this paints an abysmal picture — a continuation...

AAA: N.J.’s gallon of gas average jumps to $3.53 — 16th-highest in the nation

Voorhees-based AAA reports that the average price for a gallon of regular gasoline in New Jersey rose 33 cents over the last week to...

Florham Park law firm Schenck Price adds Moon to firm 

Schenck Price, Smith & King LLP, located in Florham Park, said Elizabeth Moon has joined the firm as a partner in its Labor and...

ICON Real Estate Advisors arranges $7.95M sale of East Orange multifamily property 

ICON Real Estate Advisors has arranged the $7.95 million sale of a 58-unit garden-style multifamily property at 223 Prospect St. in East Orange. ICON represented...

Finding the Right Pediatrician for Your Baby and Your Family

Choosing a pediatrician is one of the earliest and most important decisions you make as a parent. Many parents research online, read reviews, and...

Latest Articles

New Portal Bridge used ahead of schedule as delays impact NJ Transit riders

Train service between Newark and New York was limited Friday, with delays of up to an hour due to overhead wire issues at the...

What an ‘AI-proof’ job entails — and who’s at risk of losing out

The Bureau of Labor Statistics’ February jobs report revealed 92,000 losses in nonfarm sectors. For job seekers, this paints an abysmal picture — a continuation...

AAA: N.J.’s gallon of gas average jumps to $3.53 — 16th-highest in the nation

Voorhees-based AAA reports that the average price for a gallon of regular gasoline in New Jersey rose 33 cents over the last week to...

Florham Park law firm Schenck Price adds Moon to firm 

Schenck Price, Smith & King LLP, located in Florham Park, said Elizabeth Moon has joined the firm as a partner in its Labor and...

ICON Real Estate Advisors arranges $7.95M sale of East Orange multifamily property 

ICON Real Estate Advisors has arranged the $7.95 million sale of a 58-unit garden-style multifamily property at 223 Prospect St. in East Orange. ICON represented...